Ok...the only reason I'm blogging is because it is a requirement for class. My feelings about it? Before this course I didn't read blogs. Now I've found myself finding more blogs when I'm online. I'm still not really reading them, I'm just aware of them. It is a more effecient way to stay updated w/classmates and submitting our readings. Will I continue to blog? Probably not. Will I ever blog again? If I have to. Did it add to my learning in this class? It forced me to think/reflect about the readings and allowed me to question. So to answer my first question, I'm not thrilled about blogging because I'm not a blogger but it was interesting to read the other comments (when I had the time).
Happy Summer Reading!
Tuesday, April 28, 2009
Test Information
I really enjoyed last night's class discussion about disaggregating data. It was amazing to hear the experienced teachers and their input, they really know what to look for and do it fairly quickly. Unfortunately, I don't use the type of assessments we reviewed in class for fourth grade but it did give me insight for next school year for my students.
This class put it all in perspective for me. I realized just how important assessments are and what we as teachers can really use them for besides just stating the student passed/failed. Once we really have the skill along with understanding we can better serve our students. Yes, even those that are reading at or above grade level. That reminds me of a question/wondering I had after class. I really feel for those students who enter reading at grade level and have to read the same story 3 times throughout the year, what a waste a time for them. Why do we have to put a ceiling for those kids? How can it be modified or changed for those students?
This class put it all in perspective for me. I realized just how important assessments are and what we as teachers can really use them for besides just stating the student passed/failed. Once we really have the skill along with understanding we can better serve our students. Yes, even those that are reading at or above grade level. That reminds me of a question/wondering I had after class. I really feel for those students who enter reading at grade level and have to read the same story 3 times throughout the year, what a waste a time for them. Why do we have to put a ceiling for those kids? How can it be modified or changed for those students?
Sunday, April 26, 2009
Chapter 7: Using Informal and Formal Assessments to Inform Teaching
From reading this chapter I learned it is important to assess and to know what the assessment is telling you about your students so that it can guide your instruction. Writing and motivation assessments were discussed. A reason for writing assessments is because when a student writes "they apply skills they learn in reading" (p. 240). In the motivational assessments, knowing how your students feel about themselves as readers and towards reading can help to guide instruction. Our text stresses reading motivation because it is the "one component that remains a constant...that permeates the entire reading process" (p. 246). Based on philosopher Rousseau that any teaching method would be successfule if the learner had the motivation. Guthrie and Humenick further stated that motivation is engagement, the "cognitive commitment toward reading to learn and to extend the reader's aesthetic experience" (p. 247) with three general types: external motivation, internal motivation, and self -efficacy.
The rest of the chapter is putting it all together. This is where I need a little hand holding and explanation of now what to do. So I look forward to class and discussion of tying it all together.
The rest of the chapter is putting it all together. This is where I need a little hand holding and explanation of now what to do. So I look forward to class and discussion of tying it all together.
Chapter 6: Formal Group Assessments
Yes, I am catching up on my reading and blogging. How fitting that I'm reading about formal group assessments just as we are getting ready for TAKS this week. With our project last week, and the added stress of doing well on the creation. Now I know how my students feel taking the High Stakes Assessment. I believe our project was high stakes because it informed our professor of our performance (understanding of material) and established accountability. I mean a higher grade you were more intuned of what was required, less a grade it seems like you just weren't there. There were consequences of this project just has in high stakes assessment. I mean if you performed well then you have a higher grade and if you performed badly then your grade suffered horribly, it is worth 30% of our overall grade, in other terms one third of our grade was that assessment creation project. Comparing our assessment creation tool to the reading of high stakes assessments just makes the connection for me. The bottom line of high stakes assessment according to our text: Are schools providing effective instruction so that students make adquate progress? (p. 200). The group assessments provides an efficient way to gather the data that is needed so that comparisons of student performances, classrooms, teachers, schools, and school districts can be made. The text further stated that the assessment provides all this "useful important information without taking a lot of teacher and student time." I guess they don't take into account every single benchmark the student has had to take prior to this test on test day and the lost instruction of those benchmarks and the lost instruction when they take the TAKS, a whole day for each test. Is this not considered a lot of time, what exactly do they mean by not a lot of time? Are they suggesting hours of instructional time? If so how many? It seems to me that it is costing days of instructional time for TAKS.
The High-Stakes testing section of this chapter was interesting to read. How it originated, controversy, and guidelines are to name of few of the subsections. One controversy associated with high-stakes assessments is as our text mentioned "a snapshot of current peformance" is given, it is what a student did at a single moment instead of "providing growth-oriented assessment" no wonder the students get so stressed, it is pass or fail. This leads to another controversy. This type of testing demoralizes educators, parents, and students who receive low scores. The kid who is struggling in reading probably already has low self-efficacy and then the results of a low score just adds to it....
One last mention about this chapter, the teaching to the test, this is when educators teach content and test format that is like the actual test. The appropriateness of five practices was an eye opener for me. I provided my best guess for each one listed and got one wrong. Practice 1 violated the educational defensibility guideline (the test-prep should not increase test scores without increasing content mastery). But is what my school does, give previous form preparation allowing students to practice with older versions of the test. The released TAKS tests are on the state website so that even parents can print and help their child pass the test.
The High-Stakes testing section of this chapter was interesting to read. How it originated, controversy, and guidelines are to name of few of the subsections. One controversy associated with high-stakes assessments is as our text mentioned "a snapshot of current peformance" is given, it is what a student did at a single moment instead of "providing growth-oriented assessment" no wonder the students get so stressed, it is pass or fail. This leads to another controversy. This type of testing demoralizes educators, parents, and students who receive low scores. The kid who is struggling in reading probably already has low self-efficacy and then the results of a low score just adds to it....
One last mention about this chapter, the teaching to the test, this is when educators teach content and test format that is like the actual test. The appropriateness of five practices was an eye opener for me. I provided my best guess for each one listed and got one wrong. Practice 1 violated the educational defensibility guideline (the test-prep should not increase test scores without increasing content mastery). But is what my school does, give previous form preparation allowing students to practice with older versions of the test. The released TAKS tests are on the state website so that even parents can print and help their child pass the test.
Formal Assessment of Reading: Ch. 5
This chapter provided a bunch of information about formal assessments in relation to reading comprehension, the goal of reading. The text talked about the development of formal assessments with text blueprints and "cognitive complexity" asking from low level recall facts to high level applying knowledge. Types of scores were discussed. In this section I found the grade and age equivalent scores interesting. I guess becuase as a parent I like to know how my daughters are doing and if they are "on target" but this can be with anything from when they started walking, talking, using a sippy cup (yes the medical profession gives us age guidelines for all this type of stuff also). The text stated parents can see if their child is progressing as they should or compared to others in the same age group. A limitation to this type of test score is the comparison is what is "typical" for the nation and not for students in the particular classroom. This type of information can be misleading when comparing a student to others in the same classroom or school. The chapter then dealt with administering and scoring formal test. The terms basal and ceiling were mentioned. The basal is the point in the test where a student can answer items correctly. Making the ceiling the point where a student should miss all the items. Knowing this information a student should not be asked to answer too many easy or too many hard questions. Test bias was the last section of this chapter. In this section I learned test should not be biased meaning the scores should not give an advantage to a particular group.
Sunday, March 29, 2009
Chapter 4:Progress Monitoring
I finished reading the chapter and yes I am still behind but I did get to scratch chapter 4 off of my to do list along w/blogging! It is a good day.
On to blogging about my thinking and understanding of the reading.....
Progress Monitoring intisified with the passing of IDEA(2004) to "to assess and guage progress of all students" to prevent special education especially in reading. Our text mentioned two important components: effective instruction and accurate assessment (p.142). Therefore, students are assessed throughout the year and are compared to other students in their same grade. If progress is above or at level then all is well! If not then instruction is "intensified". In reading the text it seems that it is done immediately but in reading another student's blog there is a waiting period. So I'm unsure about this one. Our text also stated that the tools to progress monitor should be realiable and valid (p.144). How interesting it was to learn the validity of AIMSweb and DIBELS. In short, I learned AIMSweb is expensive to implement and update. This gigantic database needs resources (time, money, personnel). It tracks students and provides the all to ever important numbers, just how are the students performing. According to our reading DIBELS is not as expensive to progress monitor or benchmark. The students are expected to produce a product. This program is used in many Reading First campuses. Our campus uses DIBELS in K-3. I personally do not like one of the measures, Nonsense Word Fluency. As educators we want our students to make meaning out of what they are reading and we teach them that. Then whey do we test them on nonsense words, I can see how students can get confused and read slower because they are trying to make meaning of what they are reading. I mean I would. What is the reason/research for measuring how quickly a person can read nonsense words?
COMPUTER-BASED ASSESSMENT of READING: These types of assessments seem easier to implement and more efficient because it is all offered at one place, on the computer. Pencil/paper/palm pilots to record data are not needed. Data does not have to be entered and user friendly reports are generated. I connected to this reading b/c my daughter's school uses the STAR Reading and she'll bring home her Diagnostic Report every six weeks. With my parent goggles on I was able to understand the gist of the report.
Until next reading.....On to getting more things scratched off the To Do List :)
On to blogging about my thinking and understanding of the reading.....
Progress Monitoring intisified with the passing of IDEA(2004) to "to assess and guage progress of all students" to prevent special education especially in reading. Our text mentioned two important components: effective instruction and accurate assessment (p.142). Therefore, students are assessed throughout the year and are compared to other students in their same grade. If progress is above or at level then all is well! If not then instruction is "intensified". In reading the text it seems that it is done immediately but in reading another student's blog there is a waiting period. So I'm unsure about this one. Our text also stated that the tools to progress monitor should be realiable and valid (p.144). How interesting it was to learn the validity of AIMSweb and DIBELS. In short, I learned AIMSweb is expensive to implement and update. This gigantic database needs resources (time, money, personnel). It tracks students and provides the all to ever important numbers, just how are the students performing. According to our reading DIBELS is not as expensive to progress monitor or benchmark. The students are expected to produce a product. This program is used in many Reading First campuses. Our campus uses DIBELS in K-3. I personally do not like one of the measures, Nonsense Word Fluency. As educators we want our students to make meaning out of what they are reading and we teach them that. Then whey do we test them on nonsense words, I can see how students can get confused and read slower because they are trying to make meaning of what they are reading. I mean I would. What is the reason/research for measuring how quickly a person can read nonsense words?
COMPUTER-BASED ASSESSMENT of READING: These types of assessments seem easier to implement and more efficient because it is all offered at one place, on the computer. Pencil/paper/palm pilots to record data are not needed. Data does not have to be entered and user friendly reports are generated. I connected to this reading b/c my daughter's school uses the STAR Reading and she'll bring home her Diagnostic Report every six weeks. With my parent goggles on I was able to understand the gist of the report.
Until next reading.....On to getting more things scratched off the To Do List :)
Friday, March 27, 2009
Informal Assessment: Progress Monitoring
I found that chunking my reading and blogging about it has helped me in understanding the material better. Chapter 4 was rough for me, I think I reread the first three pages about three times, trying to figure out reliability and valididty. In summation if a reliability score is high >.90 then better the test and is calculated as 1-error. Reliability is in reference to consistent test scores. Test Validity is making sure a test assesses what it was designed to do. Now there wasn't a calculation or scores to look for so I'm not clear how one can be certain of validity? Just need clarification.
The Brigance measures different academic skills at different grade levels, (p. 137). It seems that this assessment is very thorough and provides enough information to help teachers with reading intervention or instruction. Is anyone using this assessment in their reading instruction? Or is this primarily used for Special Education?
Wonderings after this reading what is the TAKS reliability and validity? Since the results of lets say 3rd grade reading test determine if a student passes or not then I would assume the reliability is greater or equal to 0.90.
The Brigance measures different academic skills at different grade levels, (p. 137). It seems that this assessment is very thorough and provides enough information to help teachers with reading intervention or instruction. Is anyone using this assessment in their reading instruction? Or is this primarily used for Special Education?
Wonderings after this reading what is the TAKS reliability and validity? Since the results of lets say 3rd grade reading test determine if a student passes or not then I would assume the reliability is greater or equal to 0.90.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
